Verified Document

When Doctors Must Break Confidentiality To Protect Essay

Court Case On Duty to Warn: The California Supreme Court's response is that the defendants have a duty to protect not only to the patients but also to those individuals who may come under assault from the mental health patient. Thus, the defendants are negligent of and derelict in their duty in not warning Tatiana of the danger presented her by the patient's inclination. The defendants also should have insisted that the police detain the patient. As Berger and Berger (2009) point out, the duty to warn translates into the duty "to protect."

On Duty to Forecast Harm: The defendant has a duty to exercise care in the event that danger is foreseeable. In this case, it was evident that danger was foreseen, which is why the defendant alerted the police; however, the issue was not followed-up on and the patient was allowed to go free without further precautionary measures put into effect. Thus the defendant is liable because harm was only marginally forecast and not thoroughly forecast.

1.c.

On Medical Confidentiality: The defendant was responsible for communicating to law enforcement officials any threat to the security of others as a result of disclosures made in confidence. The defendant is not violating disclosure as the patient poses a...

To not communicate would be to not give the patient the proper assistance that he needs and would show dereliction the part of the therapist.
2.

According to Kipnis, the legal justifications for breaching confidentiality can conflict with the caregiver's moral obligation to maintain confidentiality: "The unhappy truth is that ethical obligations can conflict with legal ones ... Although law demands disclosure, professional ethics requires silence" (Kipnis, 2003). Further, Kipnis states that "to assume that legal obligations always trump or settle ethical ones is to blind oneself to the possibility of conflict." The sense of the conflict is rooted in the profession's "assurance of confidentiality," which if breached makes "such assurances fraudulent" (Kipnis, 2003). Thus, patients have a right to know that if they project harm to themselves, confidentiality will be broken. However, this raises issues as well: the patient may not divulge this information as a result of this sense of not having confidentiality. (Then again why is the patient there in the first place if not to receive help?) It is a complicated issue, as…

Sources used in this document:
References

Berger, S., Berger, M. (2009). Tarasoff "duty to warn" clarified. Retrieved from http://nationalpsychologist.com/2009/03/tarasoff-%E2%80%9Cduty-to-warn%E2%80%9D-clarified/101056.html

Kipnis, K. (2003). In Defense of Absolute Confidentiality. AMA Journal of Ethics. #

10, Volume 5. Retrieved from http://journalofethics.ama-assn.org/2003/10/hlaw2-0310.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

HIPAA and Confidentiality HIPAA, Confidentiality,
Words: 1677 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

From a utilitarian perspective, the improper disclosure of confidential health information related to HIV / AIDS is an absolute wrong. While such improper disclosure may actually be beneficial to the at-risk people in the patient's life, such as unprotected sex partners, when viewed from a societal point-of-view, such disclosure would be improper. Most people who know that they have a contagious fatal disease will take steps to limit other's exposure

Duty to Warn and Protect Ethical/Legal Issues
Words: 1226 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Duty to Warn and Protect Ethical/Legal Issues The situation I have chosen assumes a subject of twenty years old who has attempted to commit suicide because his parents passed away in an accident recently. The subject has been under severe depression due to a string of traumatic experiences in his life. He feels despondent and is unaware of what to do. He feels that he is living without a purpose in this

Ethics Values and Decision-Making in Nursing Practice
Words: 1664 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Ethics, Values and Decision-Making in Nursing Practice RIGHT FROM WRONG A nurse's primary tasks are monitoring the patient's vital signs, administering medications, and helping doctors treat and perform procedures (Williams, 2012). Oftentimes and in many cases, these technical skills must be guided by certain and pertinent moral and ethical principles. This ethical and moral component of her overall responsibility is so important and critical that a code of ethics was created by

Nursing and Ethics the Emotional Debate Over
Words: 2128 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Nursing and Ethics The emotional debate over abortion had been mischaracterized in the media, and hence disrupted any positive attempt to make progress in resolving the ethical and medical problems which have been created by the practice. A majority of Americans recognize and desire that abortion should be available when the life of the mother is at risk, or in the cases of rape or incest. However, liberal proponets like to

Professional Ethics Issue: The Case Where the
Words: 2140 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Professional Ethics Issue: The case where the professional ethics issue arises is a situation in which the commended obligation for journalists to safeguard the confidentiality of their sources conflict with their supposed duty to help legal authorities in the quest for justice. As a notable case, Time's Matthew Cooper and New York Times' Judith Miller are facing an ethical dilemma with two major options. First, these journalists are faced with the

Mental Health Illness the Ability
Words: 1546 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

This creates a nerve with the client that their private information is going to be unprotected and confidentiality is going to be broken . There is no safe way to keep all information private. However, all mental health professionals must take all necessary precautions to keep client information private . Conclusion As you look around the mall, classroom, church, family history, friend's family, or place of employment, you're sure to know

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now